On Christmas Day 2002, Andrew “Jack” Whittaker of West Virginia won a Powerball jackpot of $314.9 million — at the time the largest ever won on a single ticket. He was already a wealthy man, a construction company owner worth an estimated $17 million. What followed over the next few years became one of the most widely reported lottery stories in the United States, and one of its saddest.
The win and the good intentions
Whittaker chose the lump-sum option and received roughly $113 million after tax. In the first weeks he gave generously: he tithed to several churches, set up a charitable foundation, and announced plans to help local businesses and families. He was open with the press and became a well-known figure in his home state.
What went wrong
The publicity that came with the win brought problems almost immediately:
- Theft. In 2003, thieves stole around $545,000 in cash from Whittaker’s car while he parked outside a strip club. Other thefts and burglaries followed.
- Lawsuits. Over the following years, hundreds of people took legal action against Whittaker, some with legitimate claims and others without merit. He said he had faced more than 400 lawsuits.
- Personal conduct. He was arrested more than once for driving under the influence and was involved in several public incidents at casinos and bars.
- Family tragedy. His granddaughter Brandi, to whom he had been very close and who had received large sums from him, died in 2004 at the age of 17. His daughter died in 2009.
- Financial collapse. By 2007 Whittaker said that much of the money was gone; the rest was tied up in litigation and losses.
Whittaker died in 2020 at the age of 72.
| Win | $314.9 million, Powerball, December 2002 |
| Lump sum received | Approximately $113 million after tax |
| Age at win | 55 |
| Prior wealth | Estimated $17 million from a construction business |
| Famous quote | “I wish I’d torn that ticket up” |
“I wish I’d torn that ticket up”
In a 2007 interview, Whittaker said he wished he had torn up the ticket. Nearly every subsequent article about lottery misfortune has repeated the line. He also said the money changed how people around him treated him: they saw him as a source of cash rather than a person. He even described his granddaughter’s death as the price he paid for the win.
What his story is usually taken to mean
Whittaker’s story often serves as evidence of a supposed “lottery curse”. But several factors make his case distinct:
- He was already rich. The lottery did not introduce him to money; it introduced him to publicity on a scale he had never experienced.
- He chose to be public. Winners in many US states have no option, but Whittaker also sought out the press.
- He had pre-existing difficulties with alcohol that the money did not create.
- The legal and security problems followed from everyone knowing exactly who he was and how much he had.
Taken together, these factors suggest less a curse than a predictable consequence of publicly identifying someone in a small community as the holder of a nine-figure fortune.
The anonymity debate
Winner-anonymity campaigners in the United States often cite Whittaker’s experience as a case for keeping winners’ identities private. In fact, many states in the United States still require lottery winners to disclose their names, making winner anonymity an ongoing issue. Several states have changed their rules since. In the UK, winners have always been able to remain anonymous, and most choose to.
Sources

